is it just me or are the post-specific hotkeys broken? Whatever I do (even marking stuff in a post), when pressing s, r, l, q or any other post-specific hotkey, nothing happens. Neither here, nor on try.discourse.org, not in Firefox (Nightly) nor Chrome (stable) on Mac. No messages in the developer console either. topic-based Hotkeys (like shift r) work though.
Or am I just missing a special trick to make it clear which post I mean?
Weird, it wasn’t working for me earlier today (which is why I liked his response)… But now it definitely is. It definitely isn’t working on our Discourse site… (granted we aren’t up to date with master though).
Yeah, works fine if you select a post first with J or K.
I think something like this would be best, though it could get tricky:
In Gmail, there is always an email (eg post) selected. It doesn’t automatically select the one that is in view, but that would be better on this platform, I think.
In Trello, you can hover over cards and click. It works pretty well, but I wonder about the value of having keyboard shortcuts that require using the mouse to hover.
In lieu of that, #1 would at least be an improvement, I think:
Ahahaha, now I know. once you selected a post via k or j it does work. It just isn’t clear at all that this needs to happen first in the help (as the description for k and j don’t even mention posts). So, yes, the bug is a mis-communication to the user.
This ties into the “transient notification” widget we always wanted. (eg for cases where a new post pops up in a conversation and other stuff like that) I am not strongly against this for this use case but I would like the transient notification patter / widget done first.