Thoughts around simulating topics?

I remember a few topics/posts about that, most being pre-AI-era:

I guess the main thing in your suggestion is that no bots will answer; they will just start topics, right?

I don’t know from a business perspective. Maybe it’s beneficial in the long run. Perhaps it can help a community grow.

My guts tell me that I don’t like the idea of answering a bot without knowing it’s a bot, but I don’t have any particular argument to expose (though some are written in my posted links’ answers).

I’m 100% sure I have answered at least one bot at some point on Reddit in the last years or months, and I don’t like this idea. It reminds me of my dog who once tried to interact with a lifeless terracotta pig at a flea market, thinking it was a living creature (that was both sad and funny).

Now, if a topic is created by a bot, and is labelled as such, and a legitimate, constructive discussion starts between participants about the proposed topic, why not?

I hope I understood your post well, and that I’m not off-topic :slight_smile:

4 Likes