URIs to the origin of a thread that has since been merged should 503 to the merged comment

Suggestion

URIs that direct to the original thread of a thread that has been merged into another thread as a comment should redirect to the replacement (“merged”) comment.

Rationale

In a thread discussing this deficiency with the moderators of another Discourse instance, I provided some examples: [1]

  1. Consider how, at reddit.com/user/rokejulianlockhart/comments/1ait7c0 , the URI is now 404. There is no link, when visited, to the new thread that is has been merged to.

  2. That’s the problem — frequently, the URI cannot be updated. That post is an example of that. I suppose I’ll just have to learn to use a middleman (like dub.sh) that forwards open graph tags.

Mu suggestion to report it here was affirmed there, too.

Template Prerequisites

Before asking, did you search first? Press 🔍 at the upper right to search.

Yes.


  1. https://forum.fairphone.com/t/merged-topics-should-503-to-their-replacement-comment/114141?u=rokejulianlockhart ↩︎

2 Likes