What is difference between post reply and topic reply

support
1

I can’t figure out what is difference between Post Reply and Topic Reply?

replies
replies894×365 20.9 KB

4

Topic reply is to OP. Post reply is to a specific post.

2 Likes
5

So it will send notifications to OP or the post author? Any other difference apart from that?

6

In longer topics, there is a button in the bottom left corner of a post to read that specific thread.

7

This is a post reply. You can see to which post in the right corner.
Below your post there is a 2, where you can see direct replys

8

@Moin This is also a post reply to your post and I’m not sure it will show anything. Let’s see.

9

Sorry I don’t see any difference in any replies apart from just your reply which shows replied to me.

10

Sorry, yes I see now what you meant.

11

Reread my post above and try out the arrow in the bottom left of the posts in the topic. You’ll see then.

12

Yes, got it. Thanks for replying.

13

So if I reply to your reply then it is not counted as post reply? It seems that reply to reply is counted as Topic reply?

14

See the right corner of posts, why the first reply doesn’t show your name and avatar?
Both are post replies and it does show count correctly at the bottom of your reply though?

2
2825×556 41 KB

15

Immediate replies above/below have that reply indicators hidden by default. The idea there is that they’re close enough to each other that the extra context isn’t helpful.

There are admin settings called suppress reply directly below and suppress reply directly above that can be disabled so they always appear.

3 Likes
16

I still think it’s confusing. Sometimes it becomes legitimately ambiguous whether the reply was to the post right above or to the OP. Is there any reason a different icon shouldn’t be used to indicate a reply to the post directly above, like an up arrow or something simple like that?

For what it’s worth, I’m speaking as someone who uses a forum where suppress reply directly above is disabled. It is better than the default in some ways, worse in others. But I think a separate icon or indicator of some sort would be the best of both worlds.

1 Like
17

I don’t think using a different icon or convention has come up before (though “why don’t reply indicators appear” is a fairly common question). It’s possible it could simply raise “why is the icon different for this reply” type of questions instead… but that’s just a guess.

I’d make a new topic in the #feature category if you want to get more attention around that idea.

1 Like
18

Thanks for pointing that out. By default it should be disabled so that replies do show up otherwise it is too confusing for newcomers.

1 Like