Why I am Disabling the User Stats

In considering whether I should make user stats visible on our forum I extracted some of the data about the Discourse team from this forum.

From this data, i considered two questions: Who is the most complementary of the team? and; Who is the most likable? The analysis is below.

A few conclusions can be drawn.
Despite his reputation @codinghorror is clearly the most congenial of the team, giving a Like to 13% of his all time reads However @zogstrip seems to be in a particularly good mood recently and is closing in terms of propensity to like. If you get a like from @eviltrout treasure it; they are few and far between.

In terms of likability, @techAPJ leads the way getting more than 2 likes for every topic/post entry. @neil has suddenly become popular - new aftershave? @eviltrout attracts a high number of likes, perhaps from users trying to encourage him to reciprocate.

Having seen how dangerous this information can be in the wrong hands, I wonā€™t be publishing it on our site. :wink:

4 Likes

I think you may be misconstruing just what a Like signifies.

True, it may be used as a measure of popularity by some, but I donā€™t think that is the only reason it is used. eg.

  • I acknowledge having seen your post and agree but have little more to say
  • Hah! that made me smile :smile:
  • I donā€™t fully agree with you, but I think you made some excellent points
  • I appreciate your sharing that information

etc. etc.

6 Likes
  1. This information is available to anyone who scrapes the site
  2. I am not following what is so dangerous about this information.
5 Likes

Someoneā€™s ego could get so big their head would explode?

4 Likes

Wait a second, I only got 1.5 likes per post this month?

d17f514bac4d25836bf49a45ba17665d7c64a716

To be fair, my post count is pretty high. One way to game likes-per-post is to only post when you have something significant to add.

Regis has always been a like machine. In his defense, his heart is full of love.

13 Likes

This is a very strong indicator you are not posting enough animated gifs on meta. Our correctional officer will be contacting you shortly.

20 Likes

True that! Most of the likes I get is from @zogstrip or @codinghorror! :heart:

2 Likes

Thatā€™s because I :heart: you all :wink:

5 Likes

More seriously, this reminds me of things we have yet to do:

  • the default user page tab should be your ā€œgreatest hitsā€, things people liked the most that you posted in the last (n) days, or have the interval auto select like /top does

  • you should be able to tell, somewhere, the people that you like the most, and that like you the most.

  • we probably should show a last (n) days like count on peopleā€™s user cards somewhere, since it is the primary metric we care about

15 Likes

I like the idea of greatest hits, but donā€™t see too much value ā€œpeople you like mostā€, its not as if much good can result of it.

2 Likes

You say that as if I love all my children equally. Pshaw.

4 Likes

User Stats are my preferred 1.3 feature! Because it says a lot about peopleā€¦ And how the engage each others! Please improve it in this way :wink:
It push people to make the best, always :wink:

Congratulations, you got one!

Iā€™d like to echo the sentiment that this data is not dangerous at all to me. I may give fewer likes than some, but they still enhance my use of the site quite a bit: I often find on other forums I frequent that I want to hit like rather than post a reply.

In fact, I love the fact that my likes are more valuable than those from @zogstrip. :wink:

6 Likes

If by the most congenial, you mean, automatically likes any and all bug reports because of raisinsā€¦ yes.

The stats on this meta forum donā€™t really signify the same thing as they would on a regular forum because this one is being dogfooded as a bugtracker and using likes to measure importance (or something).

So here likes are a combined measure of likability as well as how useful/contributing to Discourseā€™s state of being that their posts are.
<so maybe it kind of says something that the certain someone has spammed the crap out of it yet has such a low likes to posts ratioā€¦?>

And like @sam, iā€™m not sure what exactly is dangerous about knowing how often a person hits a heart-shaped button on a forum. Youā€™re afraid people would know what members on your forum are active and not jerks, all without having to read many threads?

5 Likes

This is faulty logic.

I donā€™t ā€œlikeā€ people, I like content.

4 Likes

I ā€œlikeā€ that content! :smiley:

On my forum, there are some people whose content I wonā€™t ā€œlikeā€ no matter how good it may be, especially the guy who has bragged to me about how many ā€œlikesā€ he gets, and that therefore the disparity between his public expectations of others and his own public behavior is non-existent.

2 Likes

This was indeed completed in, I think, Discourse 1.5 or 1.6? Visit your own user page to see it.

6 Likes