Poll with restriction to groups: members can't vote

AI-generated summary

In a Discourse forum, DDo reports that members of a group restricted to vote in a poll cannot vote, despite being members of both groups that have access to the category. The issue arises even though users can post and reply normally. Benjamin_D suggests the problem may stem from the group’s “who can see the members” setting being restricted to “owner and up,” which may prevent members from voting—even if they’re eligible—possibly due to poll results revealing voter identities. DDo confirms the group visibility settings match this description and asks whether this is intended behavior or if there are plans to change it. Benjamin_D replies that he’s unsure about future changes but speculates the restriction may be tied to voter visibility in poll results. The issue appears unrelated to having two polls in one post, and DDo considers adjusting either group visibility or poll settings to resolve it. This discussion is linked to another unresolved issue regarding skipped notifications for “watching first post” emails watching first post mail not sent.

We’ve created a post with 2 polls in a category visible to users of 2 groups.
The poll was restricted to one of these 2 groups.

Then I noticed that users who are a member of the group which the polls were restricted to couldn’t vote. They get a message that they hat to be member of the said group to poll. The users are members of both of the groups which have access to the category.

Is that caused by using 2 polls in the same posting or a problem at all or does our installation have a problem (regarding my unsolved skipped notifications “watching first post” mail not sent

I believe this happens when the parameter “who can see the members” of the group that can vote is set to owner and up, ie not the members themselves.

That you for that hint - I’ll try that out.

Settings are exactly as you assumed, group is visible for owner and Moderators, members also.

There is no problem for the members to post and reply in their categories. On this background, is it the planned behaviour that they cannot participate in polls?
I’d have to change either the visibility settings or the polls for them to enable them.

Are there plans to change the behaviour?

I don’t know about that.

Maybe not but it might have to do with the fact that if the option is set in the poll, the voters can be seen in the results, not sure.