Users are discussing the lack of clear indication when posts are moved to a new topic, contrasting it with the more visible handling of ‘reply as new topic.’ iamntz notes that while the original topic shows a clear reference to the split, the new topic lacks any explicit link or notice, making the connection unclear. Mittineague suggests a yellow post at the start of the new topic could help, while AmiAthena clarifies the issue is about moderator actions, not user replies. wolftune emphasizes that both actions are functionally similar and should have the same clear indication, proposing a default ‘moved from’ notice in the new topic with an option to disable it. The consensus is that moving posts should include a visible reference to the original topic to avoid confusion.
Most of my users complains that splitting a new topic is not very obvious. I mean the newly created topic have only a small side reference to the original posts, just like there is a link into the topic.
My workaround until now is to edit each splitted topic and add at the very beginning of the topic „continuing discussion from here” (and add a link), but I think this could be automated somehow.
So the feature request is: can this be added automatically?
Other than the red highlight, there is nothing that links to the original article. More than that, even the red highlight doesn’t explicitly says something about the relation with the initial topic.
(green highlight is the moderator note)
I’m not sure how reply as a new topic is highlighted, but i assume is the same?
Moving to a new topic is much less clearly marked than reply-as-new-topic!
They are the same thing in effect! A moderator moving something to a new topic should be identical in that it is basically a moderator saying “this should have been reply-as-new-topic”. It should have the same “continuing the discussion from [old topic]” beginning to the post!
Without that, it’s quite awkward!
ADDENDUM: I see how this happens because reply-as-new-topic involves posting new text, and it’s trivial to insert the canned line about continuing from the other topic (which someone could delete or edit before posting). Whereas with moving, there’s no edit/post dialog inherently. But I still think a “moved from” canned line should be added to the top when moving. That’s the better default.
Perhaps the move interface could have a check-box for whether to include the move notice or not?