Moderation history doesn't show undelete/approval

AI-generated summary

A discussion has been started about the Moderation history not showing undelete/approval actions. Nick_Shearer_nsheare reported a post was marked as needing approval, and when approved, there was no corresponding entry in the moderation history. Instead, the post still showed as deleted by the system. Nick_Shearer_nsheare clarified that his point was the moderation history not showing the approval action, not the initial deletion. neil acknowledged the issue and suggested adding “disagree” and “ignore” actions to the moderation history logs, which currently only include actions like :delete_user and :delete_post. However, Nick_Shearer_nsheare noted that this specific issue was related to a post needing approval due to links, not a flagged post.

We had a post marked as needing approval:

when this happens it appears the spam system auto deletes it, causing this log entry:
image

and this moderation history entry:

Unfortunately when the post is marked as not spam there is no entry in the moderation history, just this log entry:

image

leaving the moderation history in the confusing state of showing the message as having been deleted by system even tho it’s visible to anyone.

TLDR; the moderation history should show when the post was confirmed as not spam (and by who).

2 Likes

Sure what do you think of this case @neil?

2 Likes

Hmm, a post needing approval shouldn’t be assumed to be spam and deleted… Have you set your site to require approval for new user posts? Or you’re using watched words to require approval?

1 Like

I think it’s because new users need to have their posts approved if they contain links.

It is weird that it was marked deleted while it was pending approval however my point was was more that the moderation history doesn’t show that someone had approved the post.

very confusing when you look at the moderation history on a visible post and all you can see is that it was deleted.

Ok I see. So we only have this way of seeing how a flag was resolved (disagree in this example):

which doesn’t show in the moderation history.

Currently we only log these things:

:delete_user,
:suspend_user,
:silence_user,
:delete_post,
:delete_topic

So we can add the other actions: disagree, and ignore.

3 Likes

I’m not sure if it makes a difference but this wasn’t a flagged post, it was one the system had marked as as needing approval due to the amount of links in it.

i.e showed up here:

1 Like