允许用户在用户资料中查看信任等级3的进度

Yes, we are discussing both of these. A bit worried about the spammers as discussed in other topics. We’ve seen them sign up in our ID system and the come to other tools to spam … although not yet with Discourse, so maybe we’re safe to do so.

Unfortunately not really. We’re providing the data but it’s @zogstrip that is doing the actual migration.
I’m currently having a conversation about importing some kind of post count indicator so that everyone doesn’t start off at the same TL. That doesn’t make sense for an established community migrating to a new platform, especially if you want to get the buy in of existing members.

Just make sure you fill in the name as well as the username :wink:

I believe the issue is a bit different when you are actually migrating content to a new Discourse instance rather than starting from scratch. Indeed, if you have enough data, trust levels will work as expected.

Is possible to get this from the API?

I couldn’t find any function to get it :confused:

55%20PM

what does this mean… “Will be promoted soon.”

When does this take effect?

Pretty sure that job runs daily - so within 24 hours.

7 个赞

so, I followed up on this and asked a bunch of the community where they thought they were and i had too many responses to ignore…

i had to manually move 4 or 5 folks to Trust Level 3 as a result. Is it possible that this may not be “firing” (a’la a job) every day?

Nope, it is working – no reports of otherwise.

1 个赞

Maybe you are affected by the group setting “Trust level automatically granted to members when they’re added” which, if I recall correctly, will then lock the user in at that level.

1 个赞

I believe this page only accounts for manually locked trust levels; it does not (yet) have a special display for group membership trust level.

Though I would think that a group giving TL2 shouldn’t prevent TL3 promotion.

3 个赞

Out of curiosity, is this feature feasible as part of core? I’m starting to see a this request from users on a few sites. Basically, there are folks who are wanting to get to TL3 but are trying to determine the time commitment required to receive and maintain it.

3 个赞

I don’t think of TL3 in terms of “earning” it. To me it’s more a recognition of participation.

Have you asked, or have any expressed why they want to be TL3 members?

If they want a title as a type of “badge of honor” maybe allowing them to have “Member” as a title would satisfy them.

5 个赞

Good point and question. I think it has to do with them having reached TL3 at one point and then losing it. They became aware of interesting topics in the Lounge and want to maintain that access.

But since these are on sites I don’t actively participate in or own (just an admin for development purposes), I’m not in a place where I can reach out for more info directly.

7 个赞

我不确定此原始功能请求的意图是否是让管理员能够看到进度,但我还希望用户自己能够看到他们的统计数据。

我们有一个围绕 TL3(我们称之为超级英雄)构建的完整计划,通过福利来培养他们,并且由于人们可能会失去这种身份,这给我们团队带来了大量额外的工作,需要通过管理员仪表板的截图来联系他们。

是否有计划让用户可以看到此功能(或将其设置为可见的选项)?有没有某种专注于达到 TL3 的排行榜功能——我还没有搜索过插件或其他东西,看看是否已经有这样的东西了,所以如果有人知道一个好的,请告诉我。谢谢!

1 个赞

这个主题有点混乱,夹杂了一些与 Feature request [1] 不太相关的内容,但我认为这一点仍然很重要:

我认为在另一个相关主题上,也有其他人提出了这个观点:

有一个新的 Discourse Gamification 插件可以激励人们参与,它有一个排行榜元素,以及可配置的评分(你可以在这里看到我们的 排行榜)。它与信任级别无关,因此可能不适合你的项目。

不过,你也可以通过你的 用户目录记录 来大致了解你离目标有多近。如果你选择“季度”,它应该会给你过去 100 天左右(多或少 10 天左右 :slight_smile: )的相当接近的统计数据。


  1. 可能值得重新开一个 :slight_smile: ↩︎

2 个赞

我对此感到矛盾,因为另一种选择是版主需要处理“我不是TL3……告诉我为什么?”的私人消息。处理这些消息非常烦人。

“秘密”规则的缺点是:

  1. 实际上,对于99%的网站来说,这并不是秘密,因为没有人会去修改网站设置,所以你可以从“关于”页面等地方找出这些规则……

  2. 这感觉就像你在玩一个规则不透明且随意的“游戏”。给网站上最受信任的用户带来这种感觉,会让人觉得不舒服。

也许这应该是一个“网站设置”。也许我们这里的默认设置并不合适。

5 个赞

我建议发布一些信息,告知用户他们是否正在朝着#3(第三级)迈进,或者关于他们是否被降级到#2(第二级)以及原因的通知,但不要提供具体细节,例如“您必须发布#篇更多主题才能晋升”。

在某些网站上,如果人们每天发布大量新主题,很多人可能不想查看其中25%(这是#3的要求),因此不幸的是,这可能意味着最值得信赖的人无法占据第三级。

如果可以通过颜色渐变或饼图来实现这一点,那将是理想的,例如,如果有人朝着#3级迈进了20%或78%的进度,这将有助于人们了解他们大致处于什么水平。

1 个赞

一个非常有趣的建议出现了,我真的很喜欢:

将其对特定群组可见……然后你可以设置让 TL3 成员可以看到 TL3 的要求,并更好地支持 TL2 完成这个旅程。我非常喜欢这个,因为它避免了 @neil 提到的许多病态现象。

5 个赞