Allow users with access to a restricted category to see who else has access

Continuing the discussion from Prioritize showing group members (not posts) on group landing page, describe groups, provide groups directory:

Thanks @downey (and @tobiaseigen). That was definitely useful to know; equally it confirms that it unfortunately doesn’t meet my requirements! To recap, what I’m after is a way for those I have invited to a private discussion group to see who else they are sharing their posts with. This is primarily to create trust and reduce inhibitions.

As per @tobiaseigen’s suggestion I am configuring access to the private categories using groups, so essentially what I am looking for is a widget that shows, on the category homepage, all the users belonging to the group associated with the category (or a selection of them, with an option to click to see all).

1 Like

Why do you need such a widget? How many people are in your groups? You could just provide a link to the group page from the “about this category” page.

Have you seen the feature that lets you mention everyone in a group at once, just by using @GROUPNAME - expands automatically to include everyone. You could put this in the “about this category” page and keep it up to date, if it’s not too many people.

1 Like

10–20 people as currently envisaged.

Thanks! That’s a pretty good solution, at least for now.

I guess adding everyone’s usernames to the “about this category” page would save a click, but we like the idea of having a more visual interface with everyone’s avatars and preferably real names. In fact, we might even want that clicking on them would then take you through to their profile page on our existing system, rather than their Discourse profile page. (We’ll be using SSO for the integration.)

A couple additional requests for this feature were made in these two topics:

I’ve merged those into this one.

2 Likes

I currently have a few categories that are locked to specific user groups. However, it’s impossible (afaik) to easily see which groups have access to that category… Even if I am a member of a group that DOES have access to it.

Yes, the category shows up and has a Lock icon next to it. But it would be great if I were able to easily see that members of GroupA and GroupB have access to Category1, and members of GroupB only have access to Category2. Perhaps a subheading under the group name… or a dropdown…

This way I can be certain WHO will have access to the post I am creating in a given category.

Short of building a feature to do this, one could put it in the About this Category topic, so it is shown to those who have said access.

5 Likes

I’m looking at doing that, but given that access might change (add a group, here, remove a group there) as the community grows, it seems useful if there were a way for people to just know at a glance who is going to see what they’re posting.

At the moment, only Admins can see who has access to a Category via the settings:

I frequently get asked ‘who has access’, and have to be very explicit in the description. However, this can be tricky when access changes a bit, or the group name changes as the Category descriptions don’t seem to dynamically update.

It would be wonderful to have a nice friendly view for those users who can see a Category that has the groups with access clearly visible. It would also be extremely helpful to have the Category moderators also available on the same view - at the moment this is only via /about or via a group mentioned in the description.

4 Likes

Interesting, we have some internal discussion going about making the relationship between groups and categories more evident that @dax is championing. We will keep this in mind.

One tricky thing we need to allow for is that in some cases secrecy is desired, so I am not sure if exposing this info is a default on / default off thing or if it is a global vs category group setting.

3 Likes

How about just using the existing category and group permissions for that?

If the category is private, then only those in the groups with access can see it anyway.
If a group is private / hidden then it would also be hidden within the category for those users.

With my small brain, I can’t see any situation where that wouldn’t work.

2 Likes