4 posts were split to a new topic: Allow skipping beginner tips when discobot disabled
Seems on all sites, users should be able to find an additional checkbox to turn off more than just the current checkbox.
There may be an age factor to the love/hate relationship with badges. The community on my forum tends to be of an older generation and some do complain about the badges being pointless and a little irritating.
There’s no right or wrong about them but it would solve the problem in one fell swoop if users could turn off the badges, or at least the notifications so the badges are more easily ignored.
1 Like
Lots of good points made by folk on the way through this discussion.
Standing back a bit to draw some principles which in turn informs the drivers for design decisions in software behaviour that then leads to developer activity to code features and switches
This fundamental question was addressed in the design of Unix and the decisions made for MS-Windows. Those once derived and understood principles may have been forgotten by a younger generation. Mobile phone UI/UX considerations constantly balance this dichotomy
The fundamental dichotomy is that on arrival in an alien environment one needs handholding in order to be able to prevent slips trips and falls. If your UI doesn’t allow immediate value generation then most users will abandon you very very fast. If somebody else’s marketing PR can point out that you don’t have a facility then you won’t even get the opportunity to compete as a decision will have been made before your users ever have exposure
As users gains dexterity or familiarity then the mechanisms required for a new user become impediments to efficient use. Psychology starts to label the aids stupid/ noisy/ chatty / lame… etc as an externalization of the frustration felt over barriers to accomplishment of known operations with the minimum of effort.
The badge system mixed and perhaps muddied two philosophical goals: one tapped into giving a dopamine hit to drive addictive behaviour, the other gave badges for first use of a feature- thus exploration of the user interface to expand familiarity- now tapping into the mechanisms that create an emotional response the frustration is to the fore - because there is no longer exploration of facilities they are now familiar. Forces are still magnetic but they’ve turned from being the attraction to now being the repulsion 
In discourse’s context a fundamental design decision buried in the past is that each instance of discourse stands alone. Indeed it may have been so encompassing and nebulous that it wasn’t even recognised as a decision at the time. One instance of discourse has no knowledge of the user’s prior familiarisation with the software.
An alternative design architecture, if the decision had been recognised might have put all forum below the users relationship with the discourse software. This architecture can be seen in the implementation of Mighty Networks.
To go back to the OP and the potentially annoying salesperson - the motivation for mighty networks was probably that this business decision makes every forum a recruiter of users that the mighty networks company has a direct ability to reach out to - in other words all your customers become recruiters for you centrally. Maybe you challenge the ethics of this (and note ethics is inescapable one of the factors in the background), whatever your opinion and choice in designing an architecture there are consequential effects - upsides and downsides. In this case it confers competitive advantage to them
Consider… .
Not THE solution but A solution would be to give of both the forum admin and the user switches to control the level of help given. Experienced users will know the switch is there and turn it off immediately. But note with just on/off for two interests there are four combinations - combinational explosion happens very quickly. It will increase software size dramatically. It has to be referenced within every other function even if only with the library call that immediately returns but with all the implications for load times memory usage etc etc - not in the silicon side (that’s probably a immaterial) but in the carbon side - there is an old acronym PICNIC.
IMH & ignorant O the entropy from the options in the discourse operating model is on the cusp of needing a simplification before it tumbles into complexity driven emergence that slowly gives new competing platforms incremental advantages of simplicity
I think this background stuff is foundational to competitive survival in the medium to long term. Not everybody in a company or a product needs to even appreciate that it is there but some people do!
Ps
I too suffer badge re-earning for skills I picked up in other discourse forum and non-discourse
2 Likes
At the risk of cherry-picking from the last post, the concept of badge-fatigue fits with the feedback I’ve had on my own forum. I don’t want to turn badges off universally but I also don’t want Discourse to irk members, many of whom are more used to ‘old style’ experiences like xenForo and phpBB.
The ideal scenario would be for individuals, perhaps at trust level 1 and above, to have an option to suppress badges for themselves.
3 Likes
All for this 
1 Like
I just registered to leave the short note that for me as a user, badges noise is the most irritating thing I encounter as a new user of Discourse. Really, do I need to get one for every single thing? First post, first link, first like, first emoji, welcome, basic, first onebox… where is the end of it? I wouldn’t care if they were simply placed on my profile page or elsewhere, but they all generate notifications. Using (and I feel an immense pressure to say “abusing”) the same notification channels, which are used to deliver actually relevant information - e.g. that someone answered to my post. I can’t count the cases where I saw that notification dot on a browser tab, switched to it wondering whether someone answered to my message, just to get disappointed that it’s just yet another useless virtual badge.
This repeats on every instance I register at. Perhaps I’m not a typical user, as I tend to register at various places and engage in short exchanges rather than staying in one place forever. I can only guess they get less annoying when you’re already through all the possible actions, but as far as I know, there exist badges for long time users too.
Moreover, if the goal of this feature is to keep people engaged (I think I saw this stated in one of other topics, pardon me if I’m wrong), then to me, it works the opposite way. When I’m pulled onto a website under a disguise of a potentially useful notification, and then only find something totally irrelevant, I feel deceived. Someone managed to steal my attention again, and I dislike being stolen from. Especially when I had my attention focused on something actually important.
Also, now I know there is that “Skip new user onboarding tips and badges” option. It’s well hidden though, I’d never think to look in the “Interface” section. To me, way more obvious would be something like “Disable badges notifications” in the “Notifications” page. But now I know and I’ll try to use it everywhere where I register (well, knowing myself, I’ll only remember after I’m already deep in a stream of badges).
6 Likes
Hmm… I agree with @aphity on this one. Receiving the super basic badges in wuite an anti-climax. Oh, I got a notification! No, it’s just First Emoji… I don’t want it to be completely turned off, however. If perhaps, there is a new feature to disable notifications for a specific badge section, say Getting Started, turning it off completely site-wide would mean disabling Nice Reply. After being on Meta for quite a while, I only received Nice Reply today. I would want to know when I get this notification, so it’s tough, really, to disable badge notifications. Also, turning off badge notifications may confue users as they wonder how come they have never received the badge in their notifications.
4 Likes
Just made a similar suggestion here:
2 Likes
What is this word that I misspelt here 
…?
I agree with this. It should probably be more visible. Currently, it is shelved away, like it’s deemed as unimportant, but you know, sometimes, we just don’t want a discobot message annoyingly hovering in our notifications panel.
1 Like