Users are discussing the absence of the ‘Dismiss’ button for new topics in category views on Discourse forums. MSealey reports that the button, previously available at the bottom right of category pages, is missing after an update. erlend_sh clarifies the issue, showing that the button appears on the top-level ‘All Categories’ view but not when drilling down into a specific category. cpradio explains that the ‘New’ filter is user-level, not category-specific, so dismissing new topics in a category would affect the user’s overall ‘New’ status across all categories. codinghorror corrects a misunderstanding, noting the button’s visibility depends on the number of topics, and sam suggests a potential implementation for a category-specific dismiss feature, though it would require careful handling to avoid affecting user statistics. The discussion highlights the complexity of implementing such a feature without unintended side effects.
Until a recent upgrade, there used to be a small, rectangular mid-grey button at bottom right of the page displaying New topics (from the ‘New’ tab at top) with the label ‘Dismiss’ or ‘Dismiss All’.
It seems to have gone in this version.
It was particularly useful when not every thread was relevant or needed to be attended to.
Now it’s necessary to click into each thread - actually twice - for them each no longer to show up in one’s ‘New’ list.
Category-level, no dismiss button: Edit: Whoops, I accidentally screenshotted Latest instead of New here, but take my word for it, there’s no Dismiss button.
I believe that is intentional though, as New, unlike Unread, is a setting on the user, not on a category. So resetting it with a category filter will filter topics/posts you are not viewing, because they are in a different category and your category view is hiding them from you.
Unread on the other hand is on a topic level and can exist on the category filter page without any repurcussions.
Huh? I’m not following your logic here. I can dismiss my New topics spanning all categories, so why shouldn’t I be able to do the same for just one specific category?
If I’m viewing All Categories, then setting “unread date” to “right now” on the user table for my Username makes sense, as I’m seeing what I’m dismissing.
But if I’m on the Bugs category and I’m seeing 2 out of 36 New Topics, setting that indicator will wipe out all 36 topics even though I’m currenting looking at 2 of them. As it will update a timestamp on my entry in the Users table, which applies outside of all categories and topics.
It makes no difference whether there is/are 1 or 10 unread threads.
It makes no difference whether I am in ‘All’ or a subcategory.
Behaviour has also changed in that - in the absence of Dismiss - I now have to go into the thread/topic and click at least twice on the (often single) post before it stops contributing the the New count.