Inconsistency editing topics


(Stephen) #1

If I edit a topic that has responses, to either fix a title, add a tag, or recategorise, the topic remains as-is in the posting order.

If I edit a topic that has no responses, it’s bumped to the top.


(cpradio) #2

This is intentional, as you are in essence editing the last post, which bumps the topic to the top too.


(Stephen) #3

I understand why it’s happening technically, although I keep that speculation out of my reports.

Either way it’s poor UX. It bumps posts that nobody responded to towards the top of the latest page, pushing active discussions down.


(cpradio) #4

Unless you account for: “They could have altered the intent of the topic or its content to where it has now become a different discussion that may be of interest now”


(Sam Saffron) #5

Regardless, this is not a bug, it is by design, feel free to propose a new design but keep in mind that by disabling bump behaviour you would have some pretty serious side effects.


(Stephen) #6

To clarify:

  • editing the title, or adding tags to a thread that has no responses is an intentional bump
  • editing the title or tagging a thread that has responses doesn’t bump the thread

The above behaviour is intentional and by design, rather than a side effect of the criteria of an edit on the most recent post in the thread?


(Jeff Atwood) #7

Editing the last post in the topic, whether that topic has zero replies or 12, will bump.


(Stephen) #8

I guess that’s the problem here, technically the topic title and tags are considered part of the first post, which can also be the last if there are zero replies, but to a user they’re properties of the thread.


(Jeff Atwood) #9

Sure, I can see category, but edits to the body of the first post, if the first post is the only post in the topic, is certainly a bump. And title, too, IMO.


(Stephen) #10

That prevents our community manager from doing basic housekeeping though.

If a title needs correcting (or amendment, for whatever reason) or tagging for future discoverability it pushes current discussion down on latest.


(Jeff Atwood) #11

Add a reply to the topic if that’s the case – is there any reason these topics must have zero replies?


(Stephen) #12

I’m not sure how that helps. These are topics that nobody has responded to, that nobody wants to respond to for whatever reason. Tidying them up shouldn’t thrust them back to the front, surely?


(Sam Saffron) #13

There was some talk of allowing a “non bumping mod/admin edit” but none of our paying customers ever asked for this so its not super high on our list. Its a mod/admin feature we would be open to adding if there was demand.


Editing posts in a topic bumps them up, at times