Hi, sorry about the long title, but I’ve recently come across a bug in Discourse. The title pretty much explains what the bug is, here are the steps to reproduce it (also known as repro steps):
-
Quote the main post on a topic.
-
Copy the text that shows up in your reply when the post is quoted.
-
Press cancel and make a new post that isn’t a reply to the main post.
-
Paste the new quote into your reply and press the reply button.
-
Scroll up to the top post. It should say that it has one or more replies. If you tap the button that says __ replies, you should see your post there.
This isn’t intentional, is it? Can someone confirm that it is, indeed, a bug?
Also, I’ve seen this on both our forums and Discourse Meta, I just tested it on Try Discourse.
2 Likes
You can’t delete posts as a normal user, only mark them for possible deletion in 24 hours.
So step three above in your repro makes no sense, it is impossible.
1 Like
I meant press cancel, I’ll edit it now.
3 Likes
Are you saying that you don’t think a post which quotes another post should be considered a reply? Because it is a reply. If a post quotes five different posts, it is in fact a reply to all five of those other posts.
If you quote a post, you are replying to that post.
6 Likes
In that case, I suppose this isn’t a bug. However, since you seem to intend to keep this feature, I would recommend making this happen with quotes from replies to topics, as it currently only happens when you quote the main post.
EDIT: Never mind, this was an error on my part, feel free to close if you want.
Also, now that I think about it, I agree that this feature should be kept.
3 Likes
I’m not clear exactly what steps you took or what you think should be happening.
I just tested on my localhost.
Made posts #1, #2, #3, #4
(posts 2 and 4 were “buffer posts” to get around the “suppress directly after / before” setting)
Post 5 did a Reply to post 1, clicked the Quote icon, copied it, canceled.
Then did Reply to post 3, and pasted in the copied quote.
Then post 6 did a select, quote reply, copy, cancel of post 2
and did a Reply to post 4
In each case both the post that had the quote copied and the post that was replied to got an expandable
1 Reply v
But only the post that was replied to showed the “arrow avatar name” in the post that did the quoting and replying.
I have a feeling your testing didn’t take the “suppress” into consideration.
Everything went as expected in my testing as far as I could see.
4 Likes