Topics with no responses doesn't count same author response

camilaoliveira · February 27, 2023, 7:50pm

The report of topics with no response (/admin/reports/topics_with_no_response) isn’t couting the topics that have a reply from the author of the original post as “with response”.
If a category has all topics with at least an reply, but 3 of the topics only have a reply from the op author, there would be 3 topics with no response.

JammyDodger · June 20, 2023, 10:44am

Sorry for the delayed response, but I think this is working as intended. The Topics With No Response report is specifically looking for topics which haven’t picked up a reply from someone other than the OP:

github.com

discourse/discourse/blob/cee15d4177bee7f4302ffba66055ab8f90b1c244/app/models/topic.rb#L1779


      
            builder.where("t.archetype <> '#{Archetype.private_message}'")
            builder.where("t.deleted_at IS NULL")
            builder.query_hash
          end
          
          WITH_NO_RESPONSE_TOTAL_SQL ||= <<-SQL
            SELECT COUNT(*) as count
            FROM (
              SELECT t.id, MIN(p.post_number) first_reply
              FROM topics t
              LEFT JOIN posts p ON p.topic_id = t.id AND p.user_id != t.user_id AND p.deleted_at IS NULL AND p.post_type = #{Post.types[:regular]}
              /*where*/
              GROUP BY t.id
            ) tt
            WHERE tt.first_reply IS NULL OR tt.first_reply < 2
          SQL
          
          def self.with_no_response_total(opts = {})
            builder = DB.build(WITH_NO_RESPONSE_TOTAL_SQL)
            if opts[:category_id]
              if opts[:include_subcategories]

So if three of those topics have only the OP talking and no one else joining in then they would be considered not to have received a response yet.

Topic		Replies	Views
Replicating the query behind 'topics with no response' Data & reporting sql-query	1	462	March 1, 2023
How to find topics without a reply from someone other than the topic owner? Support	0	1201	February 15, 2021
How many views a topic (with no replies) has got? Support topic-map	3	447	December 21, 2023
Topics where user mentioned and hasn’t responded after being mentioned Data & reporting sql-query , mentions	2	140	March 18, 2019
How to find my replies that didn't get a reply? Support	7	864	July 30, 2019

Topics with no responses doesn't count same author response

Related topics