Vicious flagging/editing cycle


#1

A problem with the way community flagging works as previously described

While a moderator isn’t around, watching like a hawk, this causes a two-part problem:

  1. A user can do the bare minimum of editing by adding/removing a couple words to get his (completely unacceptable) post unhidden.

  2. The users who flagged the comment, now can’t re-flag the slightly-edited comment because they flagged the original version and their “undo flag” option is now gone.

You may not have enough TL1+ users on a low-traffic topic to again hide the unacceptable comment, and it stays up (i.e. all weekend, with angry users responding) until an editor comes in to take a look.


(Jeff Atwood) #2

Part 2 there seems like a bug. There was never the intention that once you flag something you can never flag it again. Can you have a look @neil?


(Neil Lalonde) #3

I had a look at fixing that, and it’s tricky. The current code re-uses the logic for disagreeing with a flag, which prevents those people from flagging the same post again. I fix.


(Jeff Atwood) #4

While @neil is working on this I wanted to add that a user who makes bad faith flagged post edits should almost certainly be suspended, or at the very least given a serious warning PM.


(Jeff Atwood) #5

Did we fix this? It’s a problem if people cannot re flag edited content that was previously flagged to threshold.


(Neil Lalonde) #6

I just pushed the fix. People will be able to flag again after a post is unhidden.


(Jeff Atwood) #8