What is "Mailing List mode"?


(Kuba Orlik) #1

What does the “Mailing List mode” do? How does it affect my notifications?

The only information given to me in the UI is:

This setting overrides the activity summary.
Muted topics and categories are not included in these emails.


(Stefano Costa) #2

In mailing list mode you will receive one email per post, as happens with traditional mailing lists. This is desirable if you prefer to interact via email, without visiting the forum website.


(Allen - Watchman Monitoring) #3

or, you might set it as default if you want your end users to get regular notices of all traffic in all categories, by default.

Useful for closed systems with known sets of users who should be seeing all content. Not as great for public forums, where so much email might be a turn off.


(Kuba Orlik) #4

Cool! When enabled, is there a way to prevent it from sending me email notification about my own messages?


(Felix Freiberger) #5

This has been a very common feature request, but hasn’t been implemented yet :sadpanda:


(Allen - Watchman Monitoring) #6

hilariously, if you’re just “watching” a topic, you’ll get all the emails, with context, and you won’t get your own posts.

There’s really no winning that battle… as many people hate getting their own posts, as worry their post didn’t go through if they didn’t see it echo’d back.

It’d have to be a per-user preference, and I can’t guess if it’s better to have it off or on by default (though on seems better, since people are more likely to act on “I wish I didn’t get my own posts” than they are to guess they could turn on an option to "get my own posts)

there’s many topics on meta about this already, though, no clear winner.


(Felix Freiberger) #7

Looking at your post, I was starting to wonder…

Would limiting echoing to posts made via mail make sense? There, some confirmation is nice – on the web, you already saw your post go through.


Option to disable own post notification in "mailing list mode"
(Allen - Watchman Monitoring) #8

The Felix, that’s the first suggestion I remember reading which can really help cut through the debate. Nice.


(Jo Erlend Schinstad) #9

Does this also mean users can also respond to posts by email and it’ll appear as if added as a normal comment though Discourse?


(Stefano Costa) #10

Yes, provided you configure “email reply support” appropriately:


(Jo Erlend Schinstad) #11

Wow, that sounds awesome. It depends on well it works in practice, of course, but if it can really be usable as a mailing list system as well as a commenting system, that’s pretty fantastic.