Hey guys, both settings are working as intended. They work like this.
-
If the WP Discourse setting “Publish as Unlisted Topics” is checked, the WP discourse plugin will publish Discourse topics as unlisted.
-
If the Discourse site setting “embed unlisted” is checked, embedded topics, which include (but are not limited to) WP Discourse topics, will be unlisted.
If either setting is enabled then the topics published by the WP Discourse plugin will be unlisted. If you don’t want the topics published by the WP Discourse plugin to be unlisted then don’t have either setting enabled. I think I’m going to make a video covering this as there still seems to be confusion about it.
WP Discourse topics have always been embedded topics. The status quo ante, i.e. that embed unlisted excludes WP Discourse topics was inconsistent, more a quirk of history, and had usability issues of its own. As a rule, embed site settings include WP Discourse topics.
There are a number of topics on this forum where this is discussed, and some in which the alternate view is expressed. Nevertheless, on balance, and after seeing some of the reaction to the change, I do think a false default makes sense.
https://github.com/discourse/discourse/pull/26130
Let’s see if others agree.