Die Erfahrung von Tecnoblog mit Discourse-Kommentaren

Falco · 15. Mai 2026 um 17:09

Thiago_Mobilon:

5. Login-Friction

Der aktuelle Ablauf ist ein echter Conversion-Killer: Der Benutzer klickt auf „Anmelden“ → Ein neuer Tab wird geöffnet → Die Anmeldung findet statt → Der Benutzer landet auf der Community-Startseite. Zurück auf dem Blog-Beitrag sieht das iframe weiterhin so aus, als ob der Benutzer nicht angemeldet wäre, bis er die gesamte Seite manuell aktualisiert. Es ist ein verwirrender Kreislauf, der dazu führt, dass die Leute aufgeben und den Beitrag verlassen, bevor sie kommentieren können.

Seit wir das neue Embed aktiviert haben, haben sich unsere täglichen Registrierungen mehr als verdoppelt, was großartig ist. Allerdings haben sich unsere Engagement-Metriken überhaupt nicht verbessert. Tatsächlich ist unser DAU/MAU-Ratio gesunken – wir haben mehr angemeldete Benutzer, aber diese interagieren nicht. Metriken wie „Täglich aktive Benutzer“, „Neue Mitwirkende“ und „Beiträge“ haben keine Zunahme verzeichnet.

Dies beweist, dass die Leute dabei sein wollen, aber im Anmelde-Kreislauf verloren gehen und den Beitrag verlassen, bevor sie tatsächlich kommentieren können.

Dies wurde nun behoben, bitte aktualisieren Sie, um den neuen Anmelde-Ablauf zu erhalten.

github.com/discourse/discourse

FEATURE: Add in-iframe sign-in flow for full app embed mode (#39756)

main ← embed-full-app-signin-flow

merged 04:07PM - 15 May 26 UTC

xfalcox

+644 -4

Previously, full app embeds loaded on a third-party domain could not see the for…um's session cookie, leaving users effectively logged out, and `showLogin` only opened a dead-end `/login` tab the iframe never reacted to. This adds an `embed_full_app_signin_flow` site setting (on by default, gated to full app embed mode) that intercepts logged-out actions inside the iframe with a guided flow: bridge storage access if the iframe's cookie jar is partitioned, then either reload (if the user is already signed in elsewhere) or open a top-level sign-in tab and watch the session via polling. ## Flow 1. User clicks an auth-gated action (Reply CTA, Like, etc.). `showLogin` / `showCreateAccount` and the embed-topic-footer reply CTA route into the new `embed-auth-flow` service. 2. **If `document.hasStorageAccess()` is `false`** — Safari ITP, Firefox Total Cookie Protection, Chrome's 3p cookie phaseout — an in-iframe modal asks the user to share their session. Confirming calls `requestStorageAccess()` (synchronously inside the click handler so user activation is preserved). 3. Once we have access, the service probes `/session/current.json`. If the user is already signed in elsewhere (common Firefox ETP scenario), the iframe reloads to pick up the session — no popup. 4. Otherwise, a sign-in modal opens a top-level `/login?embed_signin_callback=1` (or `/signup`) tab and shows a waiting state with a spinner. The iframe polls `/session/current.json` every 3s for up to 5 min. 5. When polling sees a logged-in response, the iframe reloads. The popup self-closes once it has a session, driven by the `embed_signin_callback` query param + sessionStorage flag. ## Why polling instead of `postMessage` The popup-side callback originally posted a success message back to the opener. Discourse's default `Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy` (`same-origin-allow-popups`) typically mismatches an embedding host's (`unsafe-none`), which severs `window.opener` on the popup's very first load — and any OAuth provider redirect amplifies this. Polling sidesteps the whole opener relationship and works regardless of COOP, OAuth, or the user opening the link in a new tab. ## Setting - `embed_full_app_signin_flow` (boolean, default `true`, in the `embedding` area). - The flow assumes the iframe can receive its cookies after popup sign-in — true when the embed is **same-site to the host page** (any SameSite setting) or when `same_site_cookies = "None"` is configured for cross-site embeds. We trust the admin to enable this only on a compatible deployment. ## Implementation notes - **Browser-agnostic storage access.** `hasStorageAccess()` is the single signal — `true` on same-site/same-origin embeds (no prompt needed), `false` whenever the iframe's cookie jar is partitioned. No browser sniffing. - **User activation preserved.** The modal uses native `<button {{on "click" handler}}>` rather than `service:dialog`, so `requestStorageAccess()` and `window.open()` see a live activation token in the click handler. - **No reload after storage access.** `requestStorageAccess()` grants access for the current document; we chain directly into the next step in the same execution. Reloading would put the iframe back in partitioned mode in most browsers. - **Popup self-close is param-driven, not opener-driven.** The callback initializer keys off `?embed_signin_callback=1` alone — `window.opener` is unreliable thanks to COOP. - **API-unsupported fallback.** Without `document.requestStorageAccess`, the service opens a plain top-level login tab (no callback param) instead of trapping the user in a popup that cannot bridge cookies. - **Storage access denial is a dead-end on purpose.** The catch handler does not chain to a sign-in popup, since a sign-in tab cannot help an iframe that lacks storage access. The user retries the action to be re-prompted. - **Waiting modal.** While polling, the iframe shows a spinner and "Waiting for sign-in" message. Cancel stops the poll and closes the popup; the modal auto-dismisses on timeout. ## Tests `tests/unit/services/embed-auth-flow-test.js` covers gating, the partitioned vs. non-partitioned split, the storage-access → sign-in chain, the already-signed-in → reload path, denial behaviour, popup URL routing, and the API-unsupported fallback.

Thema		Antworten	Aufrufe
Embed Discourse comments on another website via Javascript Integrations embedding , how-to	127	306272	2. Juni 2026
Embed Discourse comments with on-page commenting? Feature	32	8463	19. Januar 2019
Embed Discourse as a full comment system on your site Announcements embedding	27	3118	10. Oktober 2026
Discourse Comments stuck on "Loading..." Support	22	2381	18. September 2024
Should Discourse make an effort to become a viable comment platform? Community Building	62	6008	25. März 2026

Die Erfahrung von Tecnoblog mit Discourse-Kommentaren

Verwandte Themen