The review was created in my forum’s language, but on another forum where I forgot to enable the plugin, I created the topic via the rails console and the topic was created in English instead of using the forum’s language 
After testing, I confirm that the review is created in English when executed via the rails command.
Using
I18n.with_locale(SiteSetting.default_locale) do
Jobs::YearlyReview.new.execute(force: true, review_year: 2024)
end
fixes it.