Emphasize certain tags / can't decide how to use them

AI-generated summary

The user is migrating to Discourse from an old forum with many categories and subcategories. They’re considering replacing subcategories with tags, but are concerned that tags lack certain features, such as prominent display on category view pages and ordering/positioning. The user wants a way to display a subset of tags or a tag group prominently for browsing and posting purposes.

The user has considered using theme components to display a tag group or category tag cloud, but also thinks about keeping a few subcategories as a bare minimum and using tags for the rest. However, they realize that subcategories are mutually exclusive, which could be a problem.

The user has come up with a solution to create a site map topic with emphasized tags, using the # symbol in the post editor to invoke categories or tags. This allows them to present and organize a subset of tags in a desired order.

The remaining question is how to present this site map. The user is considering using a custom sidebar section or injecting it into the top section of the sidebar. They also think about creating a theme component to show the contents of a topic on the homepage.

The user has two biggest problems with this solution: the inability to hover for tag and category descriptions when invoked with # in a post, and the fact that clicking on a tag that is used in multiple categories is not very useful.

i’m working on a migration to discourse. on the old forum, we have quite a lot of categories and subcategories. one of my categories has like 10 subcategories, and we have resisted adding more of them for obvious reasons.

hypothetical example:

imagine a Food category with subcategories like Asian, European, American.

i like the idea of getting rid of subcategories and using tags instead. multiple tags can be applied to a topic, and we could make many more tags without feeling guilty about polluting the schema with endless classification or infrequently-used tags. imagine tags like japanese, chinese, thai, nepalese, pasta, eggs, sautée, technique, noodles, breakfast.

but a problem i have is that the tags aren’t prominently displayed on the category view page like subcategories would be in the screenshot above.

i would love for a subset of tags or a tag group (just Asian, European, American) to somehow be displayed prominently to users both for browsing and posting purposes.

tags also seem to lack the concept of order/position.

tags do have descriptions though similar to categories which is really nice.

so despite the advantages of tags, am i right that they are missing some ‘first class’ features that categories have?

can some of this stuff be implemented via theme components? like at least displaying a tag group prominently inside of a category on categories page?

or maybe a category tag cloud with one tag group stickied inside of it? something like that could be cool.

i have considered keeping a few subcategories as the bare minimum and using tags for the rest, but my problem with that is subcategories are mutually exclusive. it would be quite reasonable to tag a topic with both Asian and European, for example.

thanks for your insight

my solution is converging on creating a site map topic with emphasized tags.

discourse is amazing software. i love how you can invoke a category or tag with # in the post editor (and append ::tag if there is ambiguity between a category and tag with the same name).

here is an example:

# Site Map

## #food
- #asia #europe #america
- #breakfast #lunch #dinner
- #noodle #soup #baking
- #technique #healthy

this allows me to present/emphasize a subet of tags in whatever ordering/organization i want.

the question remaining is how to present this site map.

i could use a custom sidebar section, but honestly if it belongs anywhere in the sidebar, it belongs in the top (Community) section. or atop Categories.

i could inject it in there with js, but hopefully editing the community sidebar section will be a feature someday.

also, i have entertained the idea of trying to make a theme component that shows the contents of a topic on the homepage. maybe it exists already though?


a preview of how that looks (with tags sort of randomly chosen):

Support

Documentation

  • #documentation:admins #documentation:moderators #documentation:users #documentation:sysadmin #documentation:theme-developers #documentation:devs
  • migrations

my two biggest problems with this so far:

  1. it seems you can’t hover for tag and category descriptions when they’re invoked with # in a post.
  2. for tags that are in use in multiple categories, clicking on a tag as shown above is not that useful. i may have to actually link to something like /tags/c/documentation/10/reference instead of /tags/reference, which kind of messes up the simplicity of the thing, but it’s not a deal breaker. it would be cool if you could do something like #reference::category:documentation → /tags/c/documentation/10/reference