Hi, sometimes mistakes happen. This is more prevalent on big boards with more members and more staff members. Discourse is currently on a course to improving the UI/X and the front end experience, like so: Introducing experimental admin sidebar navigation as one example.
Also plenty of big sites allow warnings to be appealed, even if they weren’t done in error.
It’s mostly a cosmetic thing for a number on someone’s profile, but it shouldn’t require Console access. If you don’t want to give it to staff, that’s fine, just lock it behind admin.