This discussion centers on implementing a feature to remind staff and trusted users (TL3, TL4) to reply to new user topics with zero replies, enhancing community engagement and retention. DeanMarkTaylor proposes a “reminder” system—either as a new tab, search link, or notification—that surfaces unanswered topics from new users, especially after the user has caught up on recent activity. He emphasizes that not all topics need replies, suggesting “special sauce” logic (e.g., 14 days passed or multiple staff spent significant time reading) to avoid nagging.
cpradio suggests a simpler solution: adding a navigation tab listing all topics with zero replies using a custom script. Others build on this, including Falco who adapts it for categories/subcategories, and brunoedigital who seeks to display it in the top menu for staff only.
alxpck shares a modified version filtering out specific categories and later adds tag support, updating their gist after discovering args.tagId in the Discourse API. simon addresses a bug where max_posts=1 doesn’t work with tag filters and provides a corrected script using /latest/?max_posts=1&tags=....
The community agrees that encouraging replies to new users is valuable, but cautions against coercing non-staff members. Suggestions include badges for “Quick Responders” and making the feature optional or dismissible. alxpck even packages the solution as a theme component for broader use. The consensus leans toward a non-intrusive, staff-targeted navigation tab rather than a nagging system.
I would have no problem with a forum asking its paid staff to respond to new users topics in a timely manner if they felt strongly that it would be helpful.
But not all members are “askers” some like to be “answerers”.
If Staff jumps on every new question posting a definitive reply, it could deny others the opportunity to feel helpful.
I also have no problem with a forum providing an easy way to find topics that may benefit from getting acknowledged with a reply.
I’m not so sure non-paid / non-staff members would appreciate being nagged into doing “work” if they are not in the mood to do it.
Push too hard and some may go all the way - out.
That said, maybe a “Quick Responder” Badge could be a good thing.
Encouragement and enticement can be good things. Coercion, not so much.
Dean, what do you think is the optimal/realistic timeframe for response. Do you track this - and do you know your averages and how its changed over time?
I found a bug with the code you supplied above.
Once we click that button in the header, it takes us to that page - which is fine.
And the URL becomes : /latest?max_posts=1
But when we jump back to latest or homepage, the URL never changes back.
Because of this, it fails after 3 steps:
Starting point: homepage (URL: /)
We click on the header link (URL: /latest?max_posts=1 )
We jump back to homepage or latest (URL is still: /latest?max_posts=1)
We click on the header link (the second time) : IT STOPS working at this step.
NOTE:
To fix this, I’m guessing we need to add a line of code to change the URL of the site back to the root of the site - at the end of the code.