See Latest Reply in Topic, First


(Deborah Chang) #1

I see myself creating a lot of topics like this one at Codeacademy: Welcome to our forums! Please Introduce Yourself. In this case, it makes a LOT of sense to see the newest replies first (as opposed to the oldest), because I want my community’s newest members to receive love. Does the ability to decide which reply is shown first by the topic writer (not the user) available?


(Jay Pfaffman) #2

The best solution that I can think of is to create an Introductions category and encourage people to post a new topic in that category.


(Jeff Atwood) #3

That would be a bit of a “boil the sea” solution as it would create a ton of new topic notifications for people to wade through. Not recommended.

The easy thing to do is include a jump to last post link at the top of the topic in the top of the first post, where people will land.

That looks like this

https://meta.discourse.org/t/x/93013/last


(Deborah Chang) #4

@codinghorror Good point on the topic notifications! So would you recommend @pfaffman’s solution of creating an Introductions category instead? This way people won’t be notified of every new member joining (unless they watch the category) but will see the latest introductions first.


#5

I believe Jeff meant that creating an introduction category would “create a ton of new topic notifications.”

i.e. resulting in a large number here:


(Jeff Atwood) #6

I would not recommend that, in fact I’d advise kinda strongly against it.

Instead, link to the topic in this form, with /last at the end, and whoever clicks that link will be jumped to the last post in the topic automatically.

                                                  |
                                                  v
https://discourse.example.com/t/topic-title/12345/last

I suggest you also edit this link into the first paragraph of the first post, like so:

:mega: Welcome!

Jump to the last post to see the latest introductions.

That way new users entering at the top can easily jump to the end, and have a handy obvious link and call to action for doing so.


(Deborah Chang) #7

@xrav3nz @codinghorror, got it! Thank you for your patience in explaining how topic notifications work. Problem, solved.


#8

Probably depends on the amount of new, vocal joiners. I have an introduction category and it works fine, so agree with @pfaffman :slight_smile:

It’s only a month old though … so I’ll let you know if it causes any trouble :wink:


(Deborah Chang) #9

Please, do! Is your discourse public? If so, may I join it to take a look?


#10

PM’d you the details @debryc