fzngagan  
                (Faizaan Gagan)
               
                 
                 
              
                  
                    March 2, 2021,  2:36pm
                   
                   
              1 
               
             
            
              This theme component adds a post menu button for staff users to make a regular post a whisper or vice versa.
  How to install 
  Get the code 
This is useful especially for forums where a lot of conversations happen in whisper and a staff user ends up posting something and later wants to hide or show the post to non-staff users.
             
            
               
               
              30 Likes 
            
                
            
           
          
            
            
              Nice! I remember this debate a few years ago. I have been burned by this so many times. The official response is:
  
  
    Er, the cat is out of the bag once you post as a not-whisper. Going back and retconning posts into whispers via editing is not something I can support as a feature.
   
 
I am often scrambling to delete whispers before they get emailed out and too many people notice my mistake!
             
            
               
               
              9 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                ondrej  
                
               
              
                  
                    March 2, 2021,  2:48pm
                   
                   
              3 
               
             
            
              Brilliant component!
is this possible to just make it so it appears on staff posts?
             
            
               
               
              4 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                fzngagan  
                (Faizaan Gagan)
               
              
                  
                    March 3, 2021,  7:04am
                   
                   
              5 
               
             
            
              
I’ll take a look at this request soon.
p.s. 
This is addressed now.
             
            
               
               
              2 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                j.jaffeux  
                (Joffrey Jaffeux)
               
              
                  
                    March 3, 2021,  7:44am
                   
                   
              6 
               
             
            
              Yes I think the same, it’s very easy to get wrong with whispers and this is one of the cases where simplicity has too be sacrified for peace of mind.
             
            
               
               
              5 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                fzngagan  
                (Faizaan Gagan)
               
              
                  
                    March 3, 2021,  7:57am
                   
                   
              7 
               
             
            
              My question then is, does discourse behave differently in terms of email if the post is deleted vs when its post_type is changed?
             
            
               
               
              1 Like 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                ganncamp  
                (G  Ann Campbell)
               
              
                  
                    May 10, 2023,  1:09pm
                   
                   
              8 
               
             
            
              We have this component installed, but the toggle no longer shows up.
Has it stopped working, or is it possible that we made some edit elsewhere (to our themes?) that inadvertently blocked it?
             
            
               
               
               
            
            
           
          
            
            
              It’s definitely still working on meta.
What does your setting here say:
             
            
               
               
              1 Like 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                chapoi  
                
               
              
                  
                    May 10, 2023,  1:17pm
                   
                   
              17 
               
             
            
              Ah I misread the original issue, it’s not about the general whisper functionality, gotcha! @fzngagan  is already on the case it seems 
             
            
               
               
              1 Like 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                Lhc_fl  
                (Linca)
               
                 
              
                  
                    May 10, 2023,  1:37pm
                   
                   
              18 
               
             
            
              
  
  
    
    
      
          export default { 
            name: "toggle-whispers", 
            initialize() { 
              withPluginApi("0.11.0", whisperInit); 
            }, 
          }; 
          
           
const whisperInit = (api) => { 
            const currentUser = api.getCurrentUser(); 
            const siteSettings = api._lookupContainer("site-settings:main"); 
            if (currentUser && currentUser.staff && siteSettings.enable_whispers) { 
              api.attachWidgetAction("post-menu", "toggleWhisper", function () { 
                const model = this.attrs; 
                let newType = model.post_type === 1 ? 4 : 1; 
          
           
      ajax(`/posts/${model.id}/post_type`, { 
                  type: "PUT", 
                  data: { 
                    post_type: newType, 
                  }, 
                }).catch(popupAjaxError); 
       
     
   
  
    
    
  
  
 
Apparently this code is broken. siteSettings.enable_whispers has been modified to siteSettings.whisper_allowed_groups.
You can try my fork here:
             
            
               
               
              3 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
              
                ganncamp  
                (G  Ann Campbell)
               
              
                  
                    May 10, 2023,  2:20pm
                   
                   
              19 
               
             
            
              Thanks @Lhc_fl ! Unfortunately, I don’t think I can try your fork since we’re on a hosted instance. But I appreciate your quick investigation! Maybe that will speed up the official fix. 
             
            
               
               
              1 Like 
            
            
           
          
            
            
              You can have any theme component you like.     It’s only plugins that need to be official   (or vetted)
However, I think @fzngagan  will want to fix this one up, so if you can wait it may be better in this case.
             
            
               
               
              2 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
            
              It’s actually a pavilion repo
@Lhc_fl  PR and I will review.
             
            
               
               
              2 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
            
              Do you want to add the pavilion   tag?
             
            
               
               
              1 Like 
            
            
           
          
            
            
              Yeah let’s do that and I’ll discuss if @fzngagan  wants to pass the Topic over.
             
            
               
               
              1 Like 
            
            
           
          
            
            
              @merefield  Is there any movement on this? I think it may still be in limbo? 
             
            
               
               
              3 Likes 
            
            
           
          
            
            
              It’s waiting on a (presumably trivial) org decision. I chased today.
             
            
               
               
              2 Likes