"Why Not Create a topic?" in category without topic creating permissions

Just a small nitpick I guess, but the link and text in the following image seem confusing.

From that text it makes me feel like clicking “Why not create a topic” will create a topic in the current category, however as I don’t have suitable permissions to, it sets the category to ‘uncategorized’

This seems very unintuitive to me, maybe get rid of that link (and the ‘New Topic’ button) if you cannot actually create a topic in that category?

Related to https://meta.discourse.org/t/creating-a-topic-where-permission-does-not-exist-assumes-uncategorised/18801

5 Likes

I’m almost certain we already have a bug report on this. It’s just not high priority.

I’ve submitted a pull request to fix this.

5 Likes

Many years have passed…

PR was merged, I assume this was fixed, thanks Daniel!

3 Likes