업데이트 시 오래된 번역본을 삭제할 수 있나요?

Sometimes when new features are added existing, text is edited. The issue is that only the English text is updated, while translations remain outdated until the next scheduled merge from Crowdin, which usually happens on Tuesdays.
This creates a delay: if a feature is merged on Wednesday, and someone updates their forum shortly after, they will see the new feature but not the updated texts - unless their interface is in English. This mismatch can be quite confusing.

A recent example are the themeable site settings which were merged on a Wednesday. In that case the description of the themes page was extended and “Theme settings” was changed to “Custom theme settings”. In English, this change helps users find the new location where these settings are configured. But in German, I don’t see that.

I have to wait for the Crowdin translation update - and then it also depends on when my site is updated. So it takes even longer before I get the updated text.
In this specific case, it’s “just” some guidance that’s missing. But there are other times where the meaning of the text changes completely, or the placeholders are changed, and things can even look broken.

Would it be possible to remove outdated translations in the feature’s pull request when a text string is modified? That way, users would fall back to the updated English version instead of seeing an outdated or misleading translation.

I think in most cases, a current English string is more helpful than an outdated translation in my preferred language.

5개의 좋아요

That’s not happening that often though.

I doubt that’s an actual issue. Discourse should automatically fall back to English when there’s a problem with placeholders.

Devs will forget to do that, and IMO it adds unneeded busywork. We could have a GitHub Action that does the job. But I think it might be easier to simply switch to daily translation updates.

1개의 좋아요

It is an issue. You can check any solved topic here on Meta while your interface language is German, and you will see something like


and an error in the browser console

And in this case, it took me a long time to understand the problem because the new text is not yet on Crowdin, and I thought I broke the HTML. (Thanks again for the explanation @nat)

1개의 좋아요

We had a problem with our Crowdin integration that prevented new strings from appearing on Crowdin. That’s fixed, and I switched us to daily translation updates. I’ll see how much busywork that generates and reevaluate that decision in a few weeks.

2개의 좋아요

영어 텍스트가 변경된 직후 번역이 제거되는 대신 며칠 뒤에야 제거되는 경우, 결과가 더 좋아질 수 있는 또 다른 예시입니다.

영어로 된 화면은 다음과 같습니다.

독어로 된 화면은 다음과 같습니다. 텍스트가 여전히 길기 때문에 끝에 있는 숫자가 약간 고립되어 보이며, 앞부분의 카운트는 이제 값이 누락된 상태로 표시됩니다.

이러한 경우, martin이 최근에 키를 업데이트하기 위해 만든 스크립트와 유사한 스크립트가 정말로 유용할 수 있습니다. 이렇게 하면 다음 Crowdin 업데이트가 이루어진 후가 아니라, 플레이스홀더를 변경하는 것과 동일한 PR에서 번역이 제거됩니다.