Thoughts on a plugin which turns discourse into stackoverflow

[dcohen (David Cohen)]

I know I know discourse is not a Q&A platform, and you might not believe in negative votes, etc, as mentioned in other posts. This is not a question about the philosophy, it is a technical question, so please proceed with technical answers.

I think a forum platform like discourse, and a Q&A platform like SO have a lot in common. On the other hand, despite many tries, a polished, high quality, open source clone of SO with a large community and high momentum like discourse does not yet exist. So I was wondering how easy, or difficult, would it be to create a plugin that would convert discourse into stackoverflow?

Would this imaginary plugin be something ‘hacky’ that only would work as a prototype, or would be reliable enough for production?

[hugo_lpz]

This must be broken in sub-tasks and as many plugins. You can edit this list as needed since it’s now an editable wiki

Existing plugins : .

• Discourse Feature Voting – vote ont the topic popularity
• Discourse-qa - Discourse Question Answer Plugin – vote on answers and sort them according to popularity
• Discourse Solved (Accepted answer plugin) – green checkmark for author’s recommended answer
• Babble Chat – chat
• Convert all existing topics in category to wikis

Non existing:

• How to get answer’s comments? (stackoverflow-like & tiny)
• How to have all post (answers) as wiki by default?
• Stackoverflow gamification vs Ethics of reputation: Proposal and Critique

Note1 : please turn your question into a wiki so we can collaboratively assess this issue’s progress.
Note2 : As of Fall 2018, Stackoverflow opens a team service https://stackoverflow.com/pricing

[angus (Angus McLeod)]

You may also be interested in the Question Answer plugin.

[angus (Angus McLeod)]

@hugo_lpz

Note: my list is an editable wiki post, feel free to edit it as needed.

It’s not a wiki yet, but you could ask @zogstrip to make it a wiki.

[Fabrizio_Bertoglio]

Hello,
I am not a very expert Ruby on Rails Developer. I finished my last project Bartering Apps and my next one will be a like StackOverflow discussion forum, because I am very interested in how developers find solutions to problems. Once that I implemented the current state of the art Discourse Forum plus Plugins, I could try to develop the following points:

1. How to get answer’s comments? (stackoverflow-like & tiny)

2. Downvotes…

3. How to have all post (answers) as wiki by default? (maybe)

My only hope is that I get through it

Wish me luck, I hope I am not posting something inappropriate for this discussion…
I would need some help and directions, I start one reading some discourse material and maybe cloning the github project.

Thanks
Fabrizio

[bdutta (Banibrata Dutta)]

Спасибо за этот список. Можно ли предположить, что перечисленные «существующие плагины» остаются стабильными и хорошо работают в последних версиях Discourse? Существуют ли у плагинов какие-либо стандартные критерии «качества» относительно версий Discourse?

Также за последние 5 лет были ли добавлены какие-либо новые плагины, которые могли бы приблизить Discourse к Stack Overflow с точки зрения пользовательского опыта и внешнего вида?

Кроме того, можно ли изменить кнопку «+ Новая тема», чтобы она гласила «+ Задать новый вопрос»?

И является ли поведение по умолчанию в Discourse (из коробки) выполнение интеллектуального поиска на основе частичного или полного текста заданного вопроса, чтобы проверить, существует ли уже похожий вопрос, и предложить автору проверить, отвечают ли эти вопросы на его запрос?

[sam (Sam Saffron)]

У нас есть официальное решение для этого!

Discourse Post Voting — это плагин с открытым исходным кодом, который добавляет формат вопросов и ответов в Discourse.

В настоящее время мы проводим бета-тестирование.