Filter topic with specific tag inside single category

(Erlend Sogge Heggen) #1

Running with the ideas discussed in Category Conundrums Two Deep, I’d like to take another stab at filters, but mainly to do with the Tagger plugin this time. In short, I want users to have the ability to use Tags for topic-sorting in combination with Categories, not as an alternative to it.

How it currently works:

Here I am already in the CSS category, browsing available tags.

But what happens when I try to drill further down by clicking the “css3” tag? The Category tab is reset to “all categories”.

This is not what I want!

How it should work

My assumption is that the all categories and all tags buttons work the same, and that changing the condition of one will not affect the condition of the other. Therefore, if you already have the category CSS selected, clicking the CSS3 tag should specify your query even further, showing only topics within the CSS category, containing the CSS3 tag.

The obvious problem here is that the Categories column overshadows the tags. Looking at this screen, it’s easy to forget that you’re not in fact looking at all available CSS topics – the ones without the CSS3 tags are not present! I believe suppressing the categories column (or replacing it, with tags in such instances) is a discussion well worth revisiting.

How about making the forum index menu "sticky"?
Sticky category selection
Make a multi-language forum
Category Conundrums Two Deep
Private tags incorrectly shown in tags drop-down
(cpradio) #2

Yep, this is a known limitation in tagging so far. That tags are globally searched and can’t be pinned to a category yet. Not sure if it is on any priority list to fix though…

(Erlend Sogge Heggen) #3

I’m hoping they can look at it from both sides (Tagger-plugin and Core) when it’s time to focus on improved extensibility in v1.2 (the development of which should be starting any day now!)

(Travis) #4

This is looking really good. Tagging like this is a huge feature asked for by my members.

(Erlend Sogge Heggen) #5

It seems this is possible now, to a certain extent. Example on meta:

Here on Meta we’ve got Show a dropdown to filter a topic list by tag. turned off, which makes sense for the site in general but results in a somewhat awkward display for a (not-meant-to-be-used-here) URL like this, since you’ll have to look at the recurring category to realise that you’re filtered to not just a specific tag, but a specific category as well.

Here’s an example with that setting turned on:

Also, not that many people would notice, but the URL structure is a bit weird.

Current structure: /tags/c/{categoryName}/{tagName}

Expected structure: /c/{categoryName/tags/{tagName}
(especially makes sense when the view is as on

So I’m just here to say it’s cool to see this apparently made it in at some point!

What would be really cool though (because I can never get enough feature love) is if tags could be multi-selected. E.g. I could opt to display all /c/feature topics with the tags planned and v1.5 in them.

Topic list tabs for user-customizeable saved filters
Why? It's very inconvenient to locate right sub-categories when posting