איך מכריזים על משתמשים חדשים

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

The discussion centers on how Discourse announces new users, with Derrek suggesting replacing the gender-neutral “them” with the user’s actual name for grammatical and inclusive clarity. Moin-1 notes the German translation uses “the new member” as a neutral alternative and invites comparison with other language versions. HAWK questions whether the current system needs fixing, while sam clarifies that all strings, including this one, are editable in the admin panel — though no global change is planned. Heather_Dudley defends the use of singular “they,” citing authoritative sources like APA Style, the OED, and Grammarly, noting it’s grammatically valid, historically rooted (since at least the 1500s), and increasingly standard — especially when gender is unspecified. She acknowledges that site admins can customize the message but argues that replacing “them” with the name isn’t more grammatical, just stylistically different. The conversation reflects a balance between user preference, linguistic convention, and platform flexibility.

I have a suggestion that I think is in Discourse’s purview rather than something that can be altered at the Steinberg level.

Currently whenever a new user posts, Discourse adds a message.

This is the first time Robbie has posted — let’s welcome them to our community!

Could Discourse alter its message slightly using the name token to be both grammatical and considerate to all.

This is the first time Robbie has posted — let’s welcome Robbie to our community!

I like the wording choosen in the German translation
This is the first time Robbie has posted — let’s welcome the new member to our community!

Would be interesting to see how it is translated in other languages.

Hmmmm, I feel like you are trying to fix something that isn’t broken here!

9 לייקים

Technically all strings are editable in the admin section, including this very string.

We do not intend to make a global change here, but you can amend your own site if you wish.

13 לייקים

Singular they is not ungrammatical; while some style guides have been slow to catch up to current convention, it is acceptable and understandable for most, if less common, but it is quickly catching up.

https://apastyle.apa.org/blog/singular-they

https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they/

If you’d like to make the change your site, that’s fine, but it is not more grammatical to repeat a name to avoid using a common gender-neutral term that’s been around since at least the 1500s. It’s a completely grammatically acceptable default gender-nonspecific pronoun that’s a good choice for a default when gender is not otherwise specified.

12 לייקים