Attempting to enforce 1 tag per topic in a category

AI-generated summary

Users are discussing issues with enforcing tag requirements in specific categories on Discourse. sunjam and leandrodimarco report that despite configuring tag groups and category settings, users are not being forced to use at least one tag from the defined group when posting. leandrodimarco shares detailed screenshots of his setup but still faces the issue. After restarting the process, leandrodimarco finds that the enforcement works as expected, possibly due to a configuration reset. jeromecc initially encounters the same problem but realizes it was due to testing from an admin account, noting that tag enforcement doesn’t apply if tagging is disabled globally, the user is staff, or lacks sufficient trust level.

Users are still not being forced to use at least one tag from the defined tag group when posting new topics within a specific category. These tags should still be available for use in other categories. Here is category setup we are attempting to enforce:

Tag Group Settings

Thanks so much for any suggestions and assistance!

I’m facing the same issue.
Same behavior under different users.

Is there a way to solve the problem or a fix available?

I’m using version 2.7.0.beta2
(fcbb6c4143)

Thanks in advance,

I ran a couple of tests and still cannot manage to enforce tagging by Category.
This functionality will help us a lot in a particular use case we are heading towards.

My current settings are:

  1. Category Menu > Settings

  1. Category Menu > Tags

Please, let me know if I’m missing something or some setting.

It would also be very helpful to have a more granular setting for Number of Tags per Tag Group.
Don’t you think?

Not sure If I should edit my previous replies to this topic and add this new piece of information…
But here it is.

I don’t know what happened… I started all over again.
I created a new set of tags, several tag groups, and rules.
And now it works as expected with the nice red warning…

Sorry for the false alarm.

1 minimal tag from group for a topic not enforced here either despite countless tinkering, recreating group etc… :frowning:
OK my bad, I was testing from an admin account :slight_smile:

Note that the “minimum tag validation” on a category will not happen if: tagging is disabled globally acting user is staff acting user does not have sufficient trust level to use/add tags

from How can I make the "tags" as REQUIRED when create a new Topic - #2 by techAPJ